Fight or Flight

Warming to Managed Retreat

by | Sep 25, 2021

colorful sameboard map showing sea level rise hazards on the SF shore on embarcadero

Gameboard depicting sea-level rise hazards on San Francisco's Embarcadero. Courtesy Port of San Francisco

To own beachfront property was once a crown jewel of the California dream. Now, many homes at or near the water’s edge are doomed as sea level rises, and for residents, evacuations will be inevitable. In Pacifica, there is talk of moving an entire beachfront neighborhood, and near Bodega Bay, homes have already been abandoned, and roadway managers are breaking ground on rerouting a short but vulnerable stretch of the coastal highway. In at least two communities on San Francisco Bay, planning experts have pondered the feasibility of floating homes. Away from the coast, in populated river valleys, climate change is also forcing community restructuring in response to flooding.

Now, land use experts, stakeholders, and government agencies are thinking hard about how to guide forward these transformations as painlessly as possible. In a recent article published in the journal Science, professors Katharine J. Mach and A.R. Siders, respectively of the University of Miami and the University of Delaware, make a case for managed retreat.

The concept is controversial. In essence, it means uprooting communities and relocating residents to higher ground. While levees can contain unruly rivers, and sea walls and other barriers can hold back the ocean, such hydraulic restraining efforts are expensive and often ultimately fail. Levees burst, and sea walls cave to the undercut-scouring of wave action. Indeed, Mach and Siders consider relocation inevitable in many places, and the key question they pose is how and when communities should make the move.

“[T]hroughout history, people have moved and retreated in response to climate,” the authors write.

Other Recent Posts

Seeking Friends for the End of the World

Could making friends with your neighbors be the secret to climate resilience? “All my homies are locally-sourced, non-GMO and gluten-free,” writes Maylin Tu of Los Angeles.

Refreshing Santa Clara County Rivers

Santa Clara’s National River Cleanup Day brought together 596 volunteers and resulted in over 25,000 pounds of trash collected. “It was one of the first times since the start of the COVID-19 pandemic, when we could actually organize group cleanups,” says Valley Water’s Nick Ingram

Chasing the Fireline

In California, climate change has has left a collection of wildfire hazard zone maps, published 15 years ago, out of date.

Cruising the San Pablo Spine: Video

Hop on a speeding bicycle with photographer Lonny Meyer as he travels the urban artery that is San Pablo Avenue and visits green infrastructure installations.

Overhauling Insurance for the New Normal

In the era of global warming, an invisible force, as primal as atmospheric chemistry, is coming to bear on human pocketbooks. Even if you don’t believe in climate change, insurance companies do.

Tears for Trees

I’ve watched an army of white trucks topped with cranes and chippers remove the oaks, redwoods, bays and manzanitas from around the power lines on our mountain in Napa. PG&E is felling a million trees per year and spending over a billion to do it.

National Toolkit Offers Steps & Metrics

The Resilience Metrics website is like a food-for-thought buffet for project planners. This toolkit offers a set of questions designed to get a project on track and to help participants measure performance.

Courtesy Bay-Adapt.

 That process is gaining speed now, and Mach and Siders argue that guiding this migration will result in a fairer process and a more equitable distribution of planning and resources. They make the case that planned retreat – versus unplanned, spontaneous fleeing from hazard zones – is an opportunity to bolster economies, improve social equity across communities, and even beautify them with creative infrastructure.

Floating towns are one possibility they describe. This idea has already been discussed in the Bay Area, with a draft plan for residential flotillas along the Oakland-San Leandro shoreline recently proposed by the All Bay Collective, a Resilient by Design project. Another Resilient by Design project, the Bionic Team, has proposed floating homes and canals for streets in the low-lying waterfront district of San Rafael.

The United States federal government is also paying attention to coastal climate adaptation and flooding. In Illinois, FEMA funded the full relocation of the town of Valmeyer to higher ground after severe flooding events in 1993. In 2016, a federal grant of $48 million funded what may be the nation’s first officially categorized climate relocation project in southern Louisiana. Here, the rising waters of the Gulf of Mexico have forced the relocation of residents of Isle de Jean Charles to the newly built town of The New Isle, about 30 miles north. More recently, Democrats in Congress allocated billions of dollars in September toward improving and updating flood-risk maps of the United States and enhancing flood insurance accessibility. 

Climate-related upheaval will affect communities across the world. Precipitation patterns are shifting, causing wetter, more energy-packed storms that have overwhelmed river basins and forced valley dwellers to higher ground. Germany and China experienced highly destructive flooding in July, and the Eastern Seaboard was swamped with the rains of Hurricane Ida.

These types of events will force dramatic changes in how humans build and rebuild their communities, and for some regions, with government funding and expert input, climate change just might be an opportunity for growth.   

About The Author

Alastair Bland

a native to San Francisco, is a freelance journalist who writes about California water policy, rivers and salmon, marine conservation and climate change. His work has appeared at NPR.org, Smithsonian.com, Yale Environment 360, The Atlantic and Hakai Magazine, among other outlets.