National Toolkit Offers Steps & Metrics

by | May 17, 2022

Inspiration Team A Contributor from our Next-Gen Inspiration Team

Source: Susanne Moser.

Though averting the worst impacts of climate change and building local capacity for disaster response require immediate action, the best path forward is not always clear. As a scientist who has crossed over to policy analysis and development, I know that the process can be a slog. But when I reviewed the new Resilience Metrics toolkit, a vision of coherent, stakeholder-driven, place-based planning snapped into focus.

Dr. Susanne Moser and a team of colleagues created this toolkit by distilling lessons from ten years of previous projects, many in California. Moser is a veteran climate change and social science consultant with worldwide experience. The team asked themselves the deceptively difficult question, “What constitutes adaptation success?” Once this keystone is identified, everything else starts to fall into place.

Their product, the Resilience Metrics website, is like a food-for-thought buffet for project planners. This toolkit offers a set of questions designed to get a project on track and to help participants measure performance; it also offers facilitation aids, case studies, and links to videos, books, and research articles organized by topic.

Defining Success

Local planning processes may define “success” as being prepared to protect property and well-being in extreme events, or by developing a built environment that requires fewer resources to defend. Nature-based solutions that slow climate change impacts, such as marsh-building and prescribed fire, are possible “successes” as well.

Success might be measured by the avoidance of calamity, by the speed of recovery, or by who receives recovery assistance. “There is not one answer,” Moser said at a recent forum. “One person’s success might not be another person’s success. Maybe what you really want is an engaging and inclusive process.” By measuring outcomes, project leaders can identify both the parts that are working well and those that aren’t.


The toolkit guides users to choose metrics that fit a project and produce meaningful information. Step one is a transparent stakeholder and community engagement process that aligns peoples’ priorities at the outset, incorporates diverse concerns, and encourages people to work together to achieve the outcomes they want. After developing an extensive array of potential metrics, users select final metrics according to the capacity of the team to carry them out, the ways they might be used, and whether existing monitoring efforts might meet the same need.

Coyote on a green hilltop overlooking a city.

Coyotes remain one of the most adaptable species in urban areas. Photo courtesy Santa Clara Valley Open Space Authority.

Iterative Process

Over the past few years, the increasing intensity and frequency of disruptive weather has become undeniable. The best models for temperature anomalies, snowmelt, permafrost thaw, and other parameters rely on historical data. Now that weather is diverging from historical precedent, scientists are losing the ability to predict what’s happening in real time. For this reason, adaptive management is essential in climate resilience projects.

To help with adaptive management, the Resilience Metrics toolkit outlines four helpful steps: 1) assess project scope, context, needs, risks, and opportunities; 2) plan the project by setting goals and determining primary and alternative ways to reach them; 3) implement the project through decision-making, obtaining support (financial, political, and public), and taking action; and 4) learn from actions and experiences through monitoring and evaluation. From there, project managers can adjust practices as needed. 


The essential — and daunting — task of facing the challenges of climate change lies ahead. Like many of us, I’ve personally felt the stress this can produce. As a scientist, I have watched with alarm as datasets diverge from historical norms. As a Californian, I have experienced increasingly intense and frequent wildfires, floods, and heat waves. The sooner communities throughout California and across the country start climate resilience projects, the better prepared they will be. 

“This toolkit was designed to help people identify and use metrics to navigate the adaptation process and to make adaptation itself better,” says Moser.

Other Recent Posts

Seeking Friends for the End of the World

Could making friends with your neighbors be the secret to climate resilience? “All my homies are locally-sourced, non-GMO and gluten-free,” writes Maylin Tu of Los Angeles.

Refreshing Santa Clara County Rivers

Santa Clara’s National River Cleanup Day brought together 596 volunteers and resulted in over 25,000 pounds of trash collected. “It was one of the first times since the start of the COVID-19 pandemic, when we could actually organize group cleanups,” says Valley Water’s Nick Ingram

Chasing the Fireline

In California, climate change has has left a collection of wildfire hazard zone maps, published 15 years ago, out of date.

Cruising the San Pablo Spine: Video

Hop on a speeding bicycle with photographer Lonny Meyer as he travels the urban artery that is San Pablo Avenue and visits green infrastructure installations.

Overhauling Insurance for the New Normal

In the era of global warming, an invisible force, as primal as atmospheric chemistry, is coming to bear on human pocketbooks. Even if you don’t believe in climate change, insurance companies do.

Tears for Trees

I’ve watched an army of white trucks topped with cranes and chippers remove the oaks, redwoods, bays and manzanitas from around the power lines on our mountain in Napa. PG&E is felling a million trees per year and spending over a billion to do it.

Coast Leaders Talk Graceful Withdrawal

In two brief audio interviews, KneeDeep Times asks the Coastal Conservancy’s Amy Hutzel and the Coastal Commission’s Mary Matella for their perspective on planned withdrawal from sea level rise and the crumbling coast.

Pricing Climate Risk

To get the basics of pricing the risks of climate change, you could do worse than to talk to Dag Lohmann. He knows just how much creeping climate change is changing insurance arithmetic.

About The Author

Amber Manfree

Amber Manfree is an independent geographer. Her specialties are spatial analysis, cartography, and natural resources management. Her knowledge of landscape change informs her graphic design and allows her to communicate science in insightful ways.